who are the top 5 on american idol tonight, American Idol Season 23 is heating up, and on May 12, 2025, the Top 5 contestants were revealed after a night of unforgettable performances. With the finale just days away, these talented artists are giving it their all to win America’s hearts and secure the coveted title. Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight Here’s everything you need to know about the Top 5 finalists, their journeys, and why they’re the ones to watch.
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight
Based on the latest episode and America’s votes, the Top 5 contestants moving forward are:
- Slater Nalley
- Breanna Nix
- John Foster
- Jamal Roberts
- Thunderstorm Artis
Let’s dive into what makes each of these finalists a standout and why they’ve earned their spot in the Top 5.
1. Slater Nalley: The Soulful Storyteller
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight, Slater Nalley, the 18-year-old from Atlanta, has been a fan favorite since his audition. Known for his raw, soulful voice and heartfelt performances, Slater’s rendition of “Angel From Montgomery” during the Top 12 episode paid homage to Idol alum Megan Danielle and earned high praise from the judges.
Luke Bryan urged him to “keep having fun,” and America clearly agrees, as Slater’s consistent performances have kept him safe week after week. His ability to connect emotionally with audiences, combined with his versatility across genres, makes him a strong contender for the crown Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
Why He Stands Out: Slater’s authenticity and ability to overcome early performance challenges, like in-ear monitor issues, show his growth as an artist. His performances resonate with fans who value genuine storytelling Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
2. Breanna Nix: The Powerhouse with Heart
Breanna Nix, a 25-year-old Texan, has brought sass and vocal prowess to the Idol stage. Her performance of Adele’s “Water Under the Bridge” during the “Ladies’ Night” episode on May 4 was a game-changer, with Carrie Underwood calling it a “perfect moment” and Lionel Richie praising her ability to “choke a note to death.” Breanna’s journey has been one of self-discovery, as she told PEOPLE that Idol taught her to believe in herself after years of self-doubt. Her powerful vocals and emotional depth make her a force to be reckoned with Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
Why She Stands Out: Breanna’s ability to channel personal struggles into her performances, like her dedication to her mother with Martina McBride’s “Independence Day,” strikes a chord with viewers Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
3. John Foster: The Country Crooner
John Foster, an 18-year-old from Louisiana, has emerged as a country music sensation. His Top 12 performance of “I Told You So” garnered over 7 million Facebook views and moved Carrie Underwood to tears. Luke Bryan praised his “traditional country charm,” and fans see him as a future Nashville star. John’s smooth, radio-ready voice and ability to make classic country hits his own, like Elvis Presley’s “Jailhouse Rock,” have solidified his place in the Top 5.
Why He Stands Out: John’s consistent fan support and ability to deliver polished, crowd-pleasing performances make him a frontrunner. His youth and potential for growth excite voters.
4. Jamal Roberts: The R&B Dynamo
Jamal Roberts has been a standout in the R&B lane, delivering high-energy performances that light up the stage. His group performance of Lionel Richie’s “Dancing on the Ceiling” during the Judges’ Song Contest showcased his charisma and vocal range. Fans on X have ranked him at the top of their lists, with one user calling him “the one to beat.” Jamal’s ability to blend gospel, soul, and pop has earned him comparisons to past Idol greats, and his stage presence keeps America voting.
Why He Stands Out: Jamal’s dynamic energy and vocal versatility make every performance a showstopper, appealing to fans who love powerful, soulful singers.
5. Thunderstorm Artis: The Seasoned Showman
Thunderstorm Artis, a former The Voice finalist, has brought his experience and artistry to Idol. His soulful performances, like “Is This Love?” by Bob Marley during the Top 24, earned him the top spot in fan polls with over 30% of the vote. Despite lower social media views in some weeks, Thunderstorm’s ability to deliver emotionally charged performances, such as “House of the Rising Sun,” keeps him in the game. His resilience and fanbase make him a dark horse in the competition.
Why He Stands Out: Thunderstorm’s prior experience and ability to infuse every song with soul and authenticity make him a fan favorite with staying power Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
What Happened Tonight on American Idol?
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight, Tonight’s episode was a rollercoaster of emotions, with the Top 7 contestants performing songs for a Mother’s Day tribute and Disney-themed hits. America voted live, and host Ryan Seacrest announced the Top 5 based on over 22 million votes. Unfortunately, two talented singers, Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt, were eliminated, leaving fans bittersweet but excited for the remaining finalists Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight, Gabby Samone, known for her soulful rendition of “A Song for You,” and Mattie Pruitt, the 16-year-old country prodigy who performed “The House That Built Me,” both left lasting impressions. Fans on X expressed their disappointment, with one user writing, “Gabby and Mattie deserved better, but the Top 5 is stacked!”
Why These Top 5 Are the Ones to Watch
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight, The Top 5 represent a diverse range of genres country, R&B, soul, and pop making the finale unpredictable. Here’s why they’re poised to dominate:
- Vocal Strength: Each finalist has delivered technically impressive performances, from Breanna’s Adele-inspired runs to Thunderstorm’s soulful riffs.
- Fan Support: Social media buzz, especially on X, shows strong backing for all five, with John and Jamal frequently topping fan rankings.
- Growth Arc: Their journeys, from overcoming personal struggles (Breanna) to gaining confidence (Slater), resonate with viewers.
- Stage Presence: Whether it’s Jamal’s high-energy delivery or John’s comfortable charm, these artists know how to command the stage.
What’s Next for the Top 5?
Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight, The Top 5 will face off in the next episode on May 11, 2025, performing live to secure a spot in the Top 4. With the finale approaching, expect more guest mentors and high-stakes performances. America’s votes will continue to shape the outcome, so fans are encouraged to vote via the American Idol app, ABC’s website, or text to 21523 during the live show. The winner, announced on May 18, will receive a recording contract and a cash prize, reportedly between $125,000 and $250,000 Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight.
How to Support Your Favorite Finalist
Want to help your favorite make it to the finale? Here’s how to vote:
- Online: Visit AmericanIdol.com/vote during the voting window (8 p.m. to 9:50 p.m. ET).
- App: Download the American Idol app on iOS or Android and cast up to 10 votes per contestant.
- Text: Text your contestant’s unique number (shown during the episode) to 21523, up to 10 times per contestant.
Final Thoughts
The American Idol Season 23 Top 5 Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis are a talented, diverse group ready to battle for the title. Each brings something unique, from John’s country charm to Jamal’s R&B flair, making the finale a must-watch. Who’s your pick to win? Share your thoughts in the comments and don’t forget to vote!
For the latest American Idol updates, tune in to ABC Sundays and Mondays at 8 p.m. ET or stream on Hulu the next day. Let’s see who becomes the next music superstar!
1 thought on “Who Are the Top 5 on American Idol Tonight? Season 23’s Fiercest Finalists Revealed!”